Politician · policy

Pope Francis on Women Priests

Upholds male-only priesthood (strong)

TL;DR

Pope Francis firmly maintains that the Catholic Church's ban on ordaining women as priests is definitive and unchangeable.

Key Points

  • He stated in 2016 that the definitive word on barring women from the priesthood came from Saint John Paul II and "this stands."

  • The Pope explained that the exclusion is linked to the "Petrine principle" of ministry, contrasting it with the Church's "Marian principle" for women.

  • In January 2021, he modified Canon 230.1 to formally allow both men and women to be installed as lectors and acolytes.

Summary

Pope Francis has unequivocally stated that women will never be ordained as Roman Catholic priests, asserting that this position is a continuation of prior definitive teaching. He specifically referred to the declaration by Saint John Paul II as standing, suggesting the door is closed forever on the matter. He frames this exclusion not as a deprivation for women, but suggests their vital role is better understood through a theological concept called the "Marian principle," which mirrors the feminine dimension of the Church.

He acknowledged the pain felt by some women who feel called to the priesthood but contrasted this with the "Petrine principle" associated with ministerial roles, which he states is reserved for men. The Pope has indicated that while the door to the priesthood is shut, there is a need to develop a richer theology reflecting the dignity of women within the Church's spousal or Marian aspect. Furthermore, he has supported increasing women's roles in administrative functions within the Vatican, noting that they often manage things better than men.

Frequently Asked Questions

Pope Francis's definitive position is that women will never be ordained as Roman Catholic priests. He has affirmed the teaching, first clearly articulated by John Paul II, stating that this door is closed. He frames this not as discrimination but as fidelity to the Church's established theological understanding.

No, Pope Francis has consistently maintained the Church's teaching against the ordination of women to the priesthood since the beginning of his pontificate. While he has opened discussions on the role of women deacons, he has repeatedly confirmed the barrier to the priesthood remains in place.

He emphasized the importance of the "Marian principle," which reflects the feminine dimension of the Church, contrasting it with the ministerial "Petrine principle." He also expressed a desire to develop this theology further and has increased women's administrative roles within the Vatican.

Sources5

* This is not an exhaustive list of sources.